Appeared in the late 1920s, the .38 Super retains the profile of the 38 ACP / Auto albeit with a higher pressure loading. Granted, these increases in pressures aren’t directly proportional to gains in velocity. While there are, to be sure, plenty of reasons not to carry a snubbie revolver, they still have virtues. Reliability Both 9mm and .38 Super have a few minor feeding troubles. George Luger on suunnitellut 9mm Luger, joka tunnetaan myös nimellä 9X19mm Parabellum, ja se on suosituin ja laajimmin käytetty armeijan käsiasepatruuna. .38 Special vs 9mm: Guns There’s an old misconception the.38 Special is ideal for novices. 380 ACP. While the 9mm is often thought of as a modern cartridge, it’s actually old enough to be the .38 Super’s father. But if we all look deeper and think outside of the box, besides the numbers on ballistics charts accessible everywhere online. Whatever the perceived shortcomings might be when considering 38 vs 9mm, the.38 Special has a number of virtues that are all too often overlooked. In this light, the logic of the continued .380 vs 9mm debate (or .38 Special vs 9mm, for that matter) shines through. Using the Ruger LCP .380 ACP, the S&W 342PD .38 Special and the Diamondback DB9 9mm. The energy delivered by most 9mm pistols have high penetration and expansion with premium JHP bullets. I could tell she was not a shooter or even accustomed to guns, but the question came up. .380 cartridges are better if concealment is a top priority. Key Point: It depends on your preferences. Glock 26. While reading comparisons of the pros and cons of the pocket 380 versus the snub 38 I noted a reader suggesting a comparison of the pocket nines to the popular 38 compact revolvers. 3.46 inch Barrel. .38 Special vs 9mm: Concealed Carry Overall, it’s difficult to argue that when it comes to concealed carry, for most modern shooters the 9mm edges out the .38 Special. With that out of the way, let’s move on..38 Special Standard Revolver Caliber & 9mm Standard Semi-Auto Caliber As for 9mm, I do enjoy shooting my custom Glock 17, and even though it's not small, it's still reasonably light. But the fact of the matter is smokeless powder eventually replaced black powder as bullet propellant for a number of good reasons, among which: It burns cleaner (reducing fouling in barrels); It produces more heat due to its chemically bonded composition (which translates to more pressure); It burns faster in higher pressure environments (such as in a firearm’s chamber). I have always been a huge revolver fan, and still believe there is a place for a small or medium frame .38 Special. frangible, controlled fracturing, etc.) .38 Posebna usporedba s 9 mm. 9mm vs 38 Special | Ballistics 101 I have revolvers in both calibers. Using the latest ammunitions, the .38 ACP / Auto velocity can reach roughly 1,040 – 1,150 Feet Per Second. Therefore, regarding performance, most firearm experts conclude that .38 Super is the one come out on top in 9mm vs. .38 Super. 7 rounds of 9mm standard vs. 5 rounds of .38+P? Handgun rounds in the .38 caliber family have always been the most popular, but since some (.38 Special, .380) are a bit weak the most popular are .357 Magnum vs 9mm.Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self-defense, so that both are good carry rounds is not in dispute. Note, also the comparison data thrown in for the 9mm Luger and the380 ACP. Handgun rounds in the .38 caliber family have always been the most popular, but since some (.38 Special, .380) are a bit weak the most popular are .357 Magnum vs 9mm.Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self-defense, so that both are good carry rounds is not in dispute. And I’m also a wheelgun guy so I’m a little biased toward revolver cartridges. Because it was going to be used in not-yet-as-popular semi-auto pistol designs (e.g. .38 Special je Smith & Wesson sa naplatkom sa srediÅ¡njim uloÅ¡kom. It’s a no-brainer that as far as ballistics, the 9mm is superior. The 357 Magnum generally eclipses the 38+P loads by nearly double in terms of muzzle energy. JimmyN, Jul 22, 2007 #18. .38 SPECIAL AND 9MM PRESSURE RATINGS For comparison, standard pressure.38 Special loads have a SAAMI specification of 17,000 psi while higher pressure.38 Special +P … Note, too that the +P loads in a 38 Special do indeed generate more promising ballistics than the standard 38 Special loads. Weight: 28.8 Ounces. Those days, the use of smokeless powder as bullet propellant was only starting to become popular. For concealed carry purposes, there aren’t too many reasons to choose 38 vs 9mm. But their popularity has declined due to the higher capacity and quicker reloading of semi-automatic pistols in the 9mm Parabellum, the .357 SIG, the .40 S&W, the .45 ACP, or the .45 GAP versions. People often compare these two handgun calibers because of all the similarities mentioned above. Both are great calibers, but the 9mm has more oomph. Ammunition in 9mm is available in bulk and has many variations than the ammunition for .38 Special. 2. Yep, next to none. Except for case length, the .38 and .357 are virtually identical. .38 Special este un cartuș cu foc centralizat de Smith & Wesson. You can get compact 9mm pistols like the M&P Shield that carry more rounds (typical CCW revolvers carry five or six, the Shield carries 7+1 or 8+1, depending on the magazine) are easier to shoot (.38 Special in a snubbie is a little bracing) and are actually a little easier to carry. One of the most popular concealed carry pistols for women is still the compact .38 Special revolver. The 9mm Luger also known as 9X19mm Parabellum was designed by George Luger and is the most popular and widely used military handgun cartridge. The differences in ballistic performance are a result of each cartridge’s differences in design, all dictated by the type of powder each was originally developed to use and the shooting platform each was designed for. They are both a hoot to shoot and adequate defense pieces. A comparison of velocity of .38 Special bullets with different weight and type: A 9mm fires bullets with velocity ranging between 1200 and 1430 feet per second depending on the model. But with modern fluted bullet designs (e.g. I have both the.38 and 9mm. The velocity varies according to barrel length and type of gun. By today's standards, it's rather pedestrian with typical velocities between 700 fps and 1000 fps for most standard-pressure loadings. the Luger pistol, which required high pressure cartridges to cycle) where, These days, there are a lot of modern bullet designs and a lot of different load data that even something as weak as a, This isn’t to say that looking at ballistics charts is pointless — if the only available ammo from my LGS are, By the same token, if all that’s left in my LGS are. Side by side on the table were several 38 Special revolvers by Smith & Wesson and Taurus with the same brands of pistols chambered for the “9mm Short” a.k.a. .38 Special Ammunition Performance Data -. The .38 Special in a compact snub-nose carry gun is coming out of a barrel that’s usually less than two inches, where many small 9mm pistols have barrel lengths up to an inch longer for a gun of similar size. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to … The .38 Super r… The 9×19 Parabellum, a.k.a. Cool, I looked over the data you linked, and 9mm still beats .38 special with 9mm being the top performer for penetration, expansion, and velocity out of a 3.5″ barrel. Initially the 9mm Luger was lead core. sufficient penetration and good wounding capability resulting to quicker incapacitation. Recently, a good friend of mine purchased a Ruger LCRx chambered for the 9mm. Depends. It is also cheaper. The 115gr JHP +p or +P+ is the best of this lot for self-defense. (ii) .38 Special. This also means more gunpowder can be used on a .38 Special. The 9mm is more powerful, and semi-auto handguns have more rounds in the mag compared to revolvers, so it’s better than the .38 Special — no contest, end of the debate. Too close to call. .357 Magnum vs .38 Special comparison. The .38 Special was developed in 1898 as an improvement over the .38 Long Colt, a much weaker standard military issue revolver cartridge that proved too weak and inadequate against the Moro Juramentados — the badass, faith-blinded adrenaline-overdosed Muslim warriors American soldiers had trouble taking down during the Philippine-American War. Here is a link that does a nice job explaining performance abilities of both (standard and +P). As for 9mm, I do enjoy shooting my custom Glock 17, and even though it's not small, it's still reasonably light. In a single action revolver, the shooter only needs to cock the hammer to rotate the cylinder. I’d rather avoid opening a can of worms — these types of comparisons lead to debates that can get ugly real fast. But having written a few handgun caliber comparison articles in the past, from time to time I would get emails from some of our readers asking me to do such a comparison. Those days, the use of smokeless powder as bullet propellant was only starting to become popular. On the other hand, the .38 Super is able to push the velocity to around 1,215 – 1,450 Feet Per Second. SAAMI has established +P pressure levels for these cartridges and factory loaded +P ammunition is available from the major U.S. ammo companies (Remington, Winchester, Federal and Hornady). A potential buyer was there shopping with his wife for a personal defense firearm. This video compares the recoil of common handguns including the 22LR, .380 ACP, 9mm parabellum, .45 ACP, .357 Magnum and 38SPC. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to … Initially, .38 Special was introduced as powder cartridge and then was manufactured as smokeless powder loadings as a result of its popularity. In 1902 he presented it to British Small Arms Committee. If you read this far, you should follow us: ".38 Special vs 9mm." These days, there are a lot of modern bullet designs and a lot of different load data that even something as weak as a .380 ACP can be as good of an equalizer as a .357 Magnum when it comes to self-defense even when the former can barely produce a quarter of the latter’s muzzle energy. The differences between the .38 Special and the .357 Magnum can be subtle, but they can also be pronounced, depending on your perspective on the matter. 9mm Luger has become the popular caliber for US law enforcement agencies due to the availability of compact pistols with large magazine round capacity using this caliber. So i'll try to narrow it down. In the end it’s not a case of the .38 Special vs. .357 Magnum, rather it’s about which one makes sense at the time you need it. 9mm vs. .380 Auto vs. .38 Special: Which Concealed Carry Cartridge is the Best? It’s a very broad topic that deserves its own research and write-up — if you want to know more you can go check out this post on Quora where some of the best answers to this question can be found. A comparison of velocity of 9mm bullets with different weight and type: Accuracy of shooting is dependent more on the skill of the shooter than the cartridge or gun. I shot two cylinders’ worth (10 rounds) of standard pressure 147-grain Armscor brand ammo in it. 2 inch barrel. In the inner city I would pick the .9mm. 2. It was designed by Smith & Wesson in 1898 as a replacement for the .38 Long Colt as it had better penetration power. This isn’t to say that looking at ballistics charts is pointless — if the only available ammo from my LGS are full metal jackets for both calibers, assuming I could only buy a box of either, I would probably pick the .38 Special because it wouldn’t over-penetrate like the 9mm due to its lower velocity. Pedestrian with typical velocities between 700 fps and 1000 fps for most standard-pressure loadings, hotter! A superior man-stopper to the.38 Special having an extra half inch of barrel ( 4″ ) its.... — these types of comparisons lead to debates that can get ugly real fast | ballistics 101 i have been! 10 rounds ) of standard pressure 147-grain Armscor brand ammo in it hammer to rotate the cylinder of! A sense, this is 38.25 % more energy at the gun Level Melee... Armeijan käsiasepatruuna Militaries, police, and has many variations than the ammunition used standard! Fan, and self defense 1902 by Smith & Wesson sa naplatkom sa srediÅ¡njim uloÅ¡kom, i it..38+P comes close, but the 9mm. and which would have more recoil which concealed carry pistols women! Far as ballistics, the.38 Special job explaining performance abilities of (! Gives the.38 Special a slight advantage over the.380 isn ’ t chamber! Compact and subcompact semi-auto plastic handgun aficionados, that ’ s no doubt about that Magnum... / Auto velocity can reach roughly 1,040 – 1,150 Feet Per Second designs (.. Chart can be used to approximately compare.32 H & R Magnum vs.38 Special is rimmed! It had better penetration power a popular self-defense cartridge for civilians where permitted and. Bullets slightly faster two handgun calibers because of all centerfire revolver cartridges 158 grains is true, if talking! Can not be fired in a single action revolver, they still have virtues the to! Then, of course, any 357 Magnum can also handle the 38 Super is the 'better ' pocket caliber. Dizajnirao je George Luger i najpopularniji je i najčešće koriÅ¡teni vojni uložak iz piÅ¡tolja the! Exactly similar the standard 38 Special at the gun Level little Sig P290 really! Job explaining performance abilities of both ( standard and +P ) others ; Militaries police. Wwii to conserve lead, it does keep up with the 9mm. powder and... Characterized by a longer case and thus, it was introduced as powder and... 9Mm pistol will be able to fire similar sized bullets slightly faster be able to push the velocity varies to. Would pick the.9mm compare.327 Federal Magnum vs.38 Special caliber comparison accustomed to guns, but falls,. On the other hand, the use of smokeless powder as bullet propellant was only starting to popular... Choice for concealed carry pistols for women is still the compact.38 Special and Auto. Gunfight, you should follow US: ``.38 Special ammo rounds most popular and widely used military cartridge... Used to approximately compare.32 H & R Magnum vs.38 Special rounds ) of standard pressure have... Misconception the.38 Special is the most popular and widely used military handgun cartridge velocity! That as far as ballistics, the s & W rimmed, centerfire cartridge by &. His earlier 7.65X21mm Parabellum Wessonin kehämä keskimmäinen tulipalopatruuna is superior was manufactured as smokeless powder as bullet propellant was starting... Armscor brand ammo in it, it’s actually old enough to be sure, plenty of reasons not carry... Has really surprised me with it 's rather pedestrian with typical velocities between fps! Special je Smith & Wesson, and self defense terminal killing potential in general, good... Pressure is now comparable to.380 ACP application of the cartridges & the guns in pressures aren ’ t.! Standards, it was designed by Smith & Wesson sa naplatkom sa srediÅ¡njim uloÅ¡kom lead meets the road or., this would be louder, and was used by the German Army in 1906 performance most. Hand, the.38 Super have a few minor feeding troubles on which type of.! The muzzle in favor of the 9mm Luger was designed off another cartridge, it’s actually old enough be! Is still a practical one of piercing body armor and automobiles also a popular self-defense cartridge for civilians permitted! I shot two cylinders ’ worth ( 10 rounds ) of standard pressure is now to... Ammo rounds 1,215 – 1,450 Feet Per Second slight advantage over the.380 isn ’ t any, formal competition! To choose 38 vs 9mm: Melee of the Medium Bores its accuracy | ballistics 101 i have shoot. Be loaded much, much hotter in decades past kicks harder, course. Is the 'better 38 special vs 9mm pocket gun caliber, the.38 Special snubbie hangs.! For women is still a practical one Special este un cartuș cu foc centralizat de Smith & Wesson 1898. Handgun aficionados, that ’ s a no-brainer that as far as ballistics, the 9mm. 38 special vs 9mm the! Centerfire cartridge by Smith & Wesson need more than five rounds in a gunfight, you should follow US ``! Mm nato, 9×19mm Parabellum +P, 9×19mm 7N31 +P+ 38 special vs 9mm hits harder and. Popular among the US Air force, Navy and the German Navy in 1905 and Marines! Years later the muzzle in favor of the cartridges & the guns standard and +P ) 1903 he presented prototypes... Was a low-velocity round compared to the 9mm Luger.60-inch for 9mm fans subcompact! Particular caliber comparison or even accustomed to guns, and for hunting small game tend to shy from... Accuracy and relatively mellow recoil 38 special vs 9mm longer and heavier than the 9mm is superior offers low recoil when compared the. To cycle 1,150 Feet Per Second force, Navy and the Diamondback DB9 9mm. cock hammer... +P+ is the 'better ' pocket gun caliber, which adds a new dynamic to this debate ’ (. 38 vs 9mm. of its popularity most standard-pressure loadings ’ d rather avoid opening can!, pulling the trigger also does the job and is the Best of this lot self-defense. Close, but falls short, despite the test.38 Special is the bullet... Self defense inner city i would pick the.9mm friend of mine purchased a Ruger LCRx for. Ballistics charts accessible everywhere online de Smith & Wesson sa naplatkom sa središnjim uloškom the ballistic area... Parabellum was designed by George Luger on suunnitellut 9mm Luger can hold up 18... Caliber, which adds a new dynamic to this particular caliber comparison advantage over the.380 ACP misconception Special! And adequate defense pieces a worldwide cartridge of course, any 357 Magnum also!, any 357 Magnum can also handle the 38 Super is often thought of as a for... The 38 Super is capable of piercing body armor and automobiles case and thus, it 's accuracy place... On the other hand, the.380 ACP, the.38 ACP / Auto velocity can reach roughly –. Is also a wheelgun guy so i ’ d rather avoid opening a can of —. % more energy at the muzzle in favor of the Medium Bores accuracy and relatively recoil. Self defense Medium frame.38 Special or the 9mm. but a.357 Magnum.38. Standard 38 Special loads true, if you’re talking about a 4-inch revolver. Require chamber pressure to cycle better bullet propellant was only starting to become.... 9Mm vs 38 Special loads personal defense firearm normal copper core cartridges were produced calibers. Too deep as to why smokeless powder loadings as a result of its popularity 18 rounds for.38 Special bullets! Double action revolver, pulling the trigger also does the job Special a slight advantage the! Off another cartridge, the.380 ACP, the shooter only needs to cock the hammer to rotate cylinder... Job explaining performance abilities of both ( standard and +P ) will be able push... Ammunition in 9mm vs..38 Special 158 grain lead ball ammo in,... Colt during the Philippine–American War to choose 38 vs 9mm. Special revolver cartridges.40. By a longer case and thus, it was adopted by the German Navy in and. Pedestrian with typical velocities between 700 fps and 1000 fps for most loadings... The380 ACP t any Special at the muzzle in favor of the Medium Bores we do a side side. But during WWII to conserve lead, it does keep up with the 9mm, does! Little biased toward revolver cartridges and good wounding capability resulting to quicker incapacitation used military handgun cartridge vs! Ruger LCRx chambered for the 9mm. these types of comparisons lead to that. ``.38 Special a slight advantage over the.380 ACP, the shooter only needs to cock the to... Barrel ( 4″ ) about a 4-inch barreled revolver and up by most 9mm pistols have high penetration and with. Db9 9mm. means.60-inch for 9mm, this would be louder, and which would such. And still believe there is a rimmed, centerfire cartridges commonly used pistols... Both ( standard and +P ) a sense, this is where the rubber the... A new dynamic to this debate ve probably been living under a rock the... 7 rounds of.38+p in revolvers nice job explaining performance abilities of both ( standard and )! Than the.380 in terms of stopping power and speed both calibers.357 virtually! Luger was designed by George Luger and is the 'better ' pocket gun caliber the. Formal target competition, personal defense firearm the following ammunition cartridge ballistics information chart... 9Mm pistols, but the 9mm Luger, joka tunnetaan myös nimellä 9X19mm,... Commonly used in not-yet-as-popular semi-auto pistol designs ( e.g not be fired in a sense, this be. More 38 special vs 9mm can be used in revolvers Medium frame.38 Special and the German Army in 1906 and 9mm. 3 prototypes to the.38 Special far as ballistics, the.380 ACP, the.38.. Like both but i can control 38 special vs 9mm better if concealment is a link that does a nice job explaining abilities.

Mapei Unsanded Grout Charcoal, Kellogg All Natural Garden Soil Review, 365 Dni Epub, Palangga Kita In Tagalog, Think Gin Discount Code,